S. Rodriguez or A. Rosales

[special k]

I could use a bit of pop to replace J. Donald at second base. Both are available on waivers, 10-team, AL-only, standard 5x5. I could use Rosales' greater positional flexibility, especially given Juan Rivera's fall from grace. But Rodriguez seems to offer more upside. I am in a nip and tuck race for first, a few HRs could help from either. Thoughts?

[Guest]

I would be a strong vote for S-Rod unless the positional eligibility for some reason is too good to ignore. Even then, I'd still vote for S-Rod just not as vehemently.

[Captain Hook]

If HR is the help you need then Sean Rodriguez is clearly the pick

[special k]

Yeah, grabbed SR, thanks for confirming opinion. My ship is taking on so much water I may have to get Rosales, too, though ... 10-point lead down to 2 as team looks like MASH unit. Oh, well, luck - Pena's sore foot, Branyan and Damon's cranky backs, Rivera's lost PT, Kinsler's groin, Posada's whatever - is part of the AL-only game!