Mastersball Fantasy Forum

In our AL only league we can have 5 players not on the 25 man roster or DL. Anyone else, college, minors, foreign, or unsigned (J. Dye) are available.

I am holding onto Mike Moustakas, the KC 3B, and wonder if he's poised to fulfill his promise or is going to turn into an average, at best, 1B/DH.

I'd replace him with the 30th pick in our draft which would be someone like Hector Rondon, Alex Colome, Trevor Reckling, Tanner Sheppers, Jared Mitchell or Ryan Westmoreland (yeah, I know).

In other words, the available players are plentiful, the sure things are not.

Keep Moutakas or take a chance on someone else?

Thanks ~TB

The shine is definitely off Moustakas. If you are sure there will be talent, why not drop him with the worst case being picking him back up? If nothing else, if someone else is not aware of his struggles, it pushes something down to you.

I hate it when my brilliant picks lose their shine. I was thinking along the same lines and wondered whether anyone thought it was a huge mistake. Thanks, Todd.

Couple of things , Bob

• As Todd said, the bloom is somewhat off the rose here
• You're committed to Ynoa, it seems - so that's one slot tied up for two more years at least
• I would think Rondon's arrival would be sooner than Moustakas
• We're talking KC here and the whole fun bunch they have in the front office y'know? The team that signed a fifth OF to a major league deal 300G's over the minimum and then sent him down to low A so he can try and become a pitcher?

I like MooseTacos, but he has had injury problems and of course has organizational problems so I would rather have someone with equal upside with a better path

Lots of these questions are dependant on whether you are looking for players that are more likely to help this year (Rondon) or long term potential (Mitchell....or Westmoreland IF he ever plays baseball again)

Well, someone DID pick up Moustakas (and Rondon) so for my 3 picks I ended up with Jesus Montero (#11), Casey Crosby (20), and Jacob Turner (30).

Looking long term for the best possible talent. In 2011 I'll have to bring Feliz up and the other 4 will likely not be in the bigs until 2011 or 2012. Starting pitchers go for huge sums in our league (Matusz $15, Weaver $27, Buehrle $21) so I thought I'd shoot for a cuople good ones.

Thanks... ~TB