Benintendi for K. Marte + Jared Kelenic?

[aasilver]

This is a keep forever 15 team Dynasty League. Standard 5x5 categories. Im going for the title this year and could use a slight bump in HR, AVG. This trade is about this year first and foremost but also thinking of the future.

In my mind this kind of comes down to if you think K. Marte is truly broken out for the rest of this year as well is what long term prospects are for Benny Biceps. What say you? Thanks!

Current Offensive lineup.

C Jason Castro
C Wilson Ramos
1B Josh Bell
2B Javier Baez
3B Alex Bregman
SS Xander Bogaerts
CI Anthony Rendon
MI Adalberto Mondesi
OF Ronald Acuna Jr.
OF Andrew Benintendi
OF Mookie Betts
OF Nicholas Castellanos
OF Michael Conforto
UT Gregory Polanco
B Tucker Barnhart
B Jose Martinez
B Aaron Hicks
B Nomar Mazara

[Todd Zola]

Everything Marte is doing is fully supported by the underlying metrics, so there isn't any regression due in the classical sense (good luck regressing to the mean), That said, it's obviously unclear whether he can maintain this pace all season.

Benintendi is the same guy, just performing at the lower range of plausible outcomes.

This is a matter of taste/philosophy, but when I'm going for it, I don't also have an eye for the future, even in dynasty formats. To that end, while Kelenic may be a perfectly fair deal, he doesn't help win this season. if I'm dealing Benintendi in a keep forever league, I want more help to win THIS year. Your team, your call.