Page 1 of 1

Please Help Me Decide on 5 keepers

Posted: February 23rd, 2013, 5:11 pm
by CleverNeverWrong
Hi all,

I'm in a Yahoo Mixed League H2H 7x7 Keeper League. Here's the team I just took over. The way keepers work is we can have 2 hitters, 2 pitchers and 1 flex (Hitter or Pitcher).

My roster, plus the round the player was selected in (and I would have them in this year, if I deemed as keeper).

Once we have our draft on March 27, anyone I don't choose as a keeper will be wiped away, and I will draft new players to replace.

C Mauer (round 4)
1B Adrian Gonzalez (round 2)
2B Howie Kendrick (round 15)
3B Adrian Beltre (round 11)
SS Derek Jeter (round 10)
OF Ryan Braun (round 1)
OF Matt Holliday (round 3)
OF Chris Davis (round 21)
OF Edwin Encarnacion (round 21)

SP - Yovano Gallardo (round 9)
SP Jordan Zimmerman (round 18)
SP Grant Balfour (round 15)
RP Joe Nathan (round 11)
RP Rafael Soriano (round 21)
P Max Scherzer (round 16)
P CJ Wilson (round 16)

Right now I am thinking Ryan Braun (best player, no-brainer), Adrian Beltre (a steal at round 11), Edwin Encarnacion (another steal at round 21) as well as Soriano (steal at round 21) and Jordan Zimmerman (steal at round 18)

That nucleus in my opinion gives me good draft values, and the ability to pair them up with even stronger players in the earlier rounds. Your thoughts would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

Re: Please Help Me Decide on 5 keepers

Posted: February 23rd, 2013, 7:22 pm
by Captain Hook
Agree very good players and with the exception of Braun who will always be a first rounder very good values for your other players

Re: Please Help Me Decide on 5 keepers

Posted: February 23rd, 2013, 7:24 pm
by AllstonRockCity
I agree 100% with your hitter decisions, and I will be shocked if anyone on here suggests otherwise.

I also agree with Zimmermann.

However, I don't like keeping closers. I would keeper Scherzer over either of your closers. 220+ K's in round 16 = larceny

ETA: what pick do you have? because if you have #1 overall, keeping Braun would be a mistake. Keep someone else, then draft Braun at 1.1

Re: Please Help Me Decide on 5 keepers

Posted: February 23rd, 2013, 9:28 pm
by Todd Zola
AllstonRockCity wrote:I agree 100% with your hitter decisions, and I will be shocked if anyone on here suggests otherwise.

I also agree with Zimmermann.

However, I don't like keeping closers. I would keeper Scherzer over either of your closers. 220+ K's in round 16 = larceny

ETA: what pick do you have? because if you have #1 overall, keeping Braun would be a mistake. Keep someone else, then draft Braun at 1.1
What he said.